Paying Attention with Meriwether Lewis

Updated: 5 hours ago

the rays of the fins are boney but not sharp tho' somewhat pointed. the small fin on the back next to the tail has no rays of bone being a thin membranous pellicle. the fins next to the gills have eleven rays each. those of the abdomen have eight each, those of the pinna-ani are 20 and 2 half formed in front. that of the back has eleven rays. all the fins are of a white colour. the back is of a bluish duskey colour and that of the lower part of the sides and belley is of a silvery white. no spots on any part. the first bone of the gills next behid the eye is of a bluis cast, and the second of a light goald colour nearly white. the puple of the eye is blak and the iris of a silver white. the underjaw exceeds the uper; and the mouth opens to great extent, folding like that of the herring. it has no teeth.
So runs part of the description that Meriwether Lewis wrote of . . . Can you guess? Here’s a hint: Lewis shed a lot of light on this fish from the Pacific Northwest.
In this excerpt from his journal entry for February 24, 1806, Lewis was writing about the eulachon (Thaleichthys pacificus), also known as the candlefish. Lewis knew this fish well. Before arriving in the region of modern-day Oregon and Washington, he had never seen one, but he certainly knew it well after he finished describing it (and the passage above is only part of the description).
Meriwether Lewis knew how to pay attention to details.
Do we?
A “mind that would notice a ripple in a river”
Lewis grew up outdoors. As a boy, he rambled for countless hours over the land near his home at Locust Hill, not far from Jefferson’s Monticello in Virginia. In his new book This Vast Enterprise, Craig Fehrman writes that young Lewis "roamed day or night, sun or snow, hunting with his favorite dogs for company and staying out until the region's red clay caked his clothes.”
Lewis brought a keen curiosity to these early expeditions. Fehrman explains, “He had a mind that would notice a ripple in a river, then the squirrel that caused it—a mind the would heat up quickly, tracking other squirrels, analyzing their swimming styles, and wondering what it all implied about migratory patterns.”
This curiosity well equipped him for the expedition that would make him and his friend William Clark famous. It must have helped fuel his tireless observation and documentation of the flora and fauna that he encountered on the Great Plains, in the Rocky Mountain region, and in the Pacific Northwest.
Curiosity was not enough, though. Thomas Jefferson, the major force behind the expedition, had given Lewis explicit instructions for the information he wanted him to collect. In an era before photography, Lewis wrote very detailed descriptions, drew pictures (including one of the candlefish), and collected specimens. By the time he was done, he had amassed a vast amount of information to illuminate the life of the American West for Jefferson and others back in the East.
None of these instructions from Jefferson or his own curiosity would have done much good if Lewis did not also bring something else, a crucial skill not only in science, but also in life.
Even in the midst of an arduous journey filled with trials and brushes with death, Lewis could focus his attention on details, and details matter.
The First Step to Learning
On a personal level, paying attention is essential to learning. If you have ever kicked yourself for forgetting something—maybe the name of the person you just met at a conference or a sales call—you probably blamed your memory, but how closely were you paying attention when you first took in the information? The process of encoding information is the first step to learning it. As Markham Heid explains in an article for Time magazine, multitasking can limit our ability to pay attention to something and ultimately learn it:
A 2017 study from Stanford University found that heavy media multitaskers—those who spend a lot of time using multiple forms of media at once, like listening to a podcast while surfing online—tend to do worse on tests of working memory and long-term memory than light media multitaskers. More research finds that relying on your device’s GPS functionality hampers your ability to navigate on your own. You can’t remember something well if you didn’t pay much attention to it in the first place, it seems.
Clearly, Lewis had an advantage over us: no viral YouTube videos, no TikTok, no incoming texts from Jefferson (“Are you there yet? Are you there yet?”). If we want to do a better job of encoding information, we can pretend to be living in 1806 and focus on the people, objects, and places actually in front of us instead of the images of people, objects, and places on our devices. Try this and see how much better you are at absorbing and remembering information.
Paying attention to details is important on a broader scale, too. We can’t fully understand something without seeing the details, and we can’t solve problems we don’t fully understand.
What is it?
Of course, this level of detail is valuable to botanists and zoologists, who are interested in, among other things, differences that may distinguish between species. Knowing that, for example, a candlefish contains a lot of oil would also interest traders and manufacturers looking for opportunities. (In another part of his description, Lewis noted that the candlefish was also delicious.)
Details, however, have much broader significance and should interest more than just scientists and people looking to make a buck.
In ancient rhetoric, one of the first steps in formulating an argument is definition—that is, determining exactly what something is. Before we can have a productive argument about freedom of speech, for instance, we need to agree on what constitutes speech. (Sometimes, the real point of disagreement between two parties is actually definition. Two people may agree that the U.S. government generally should not restrict free speech, but disagree on whether making donations to a political candidate constitutes a form of speech.)
Defining something—a plant, an animal, a form of expression, a kind of technology—requires attention to detail. The pervasive presence of artificial intelligence in our world today has given rise to some important questions of definition. Is AI conscious? Hmm, well, what does it mean to be “conscious”? What details in the nature and actions of AI make the case that it qualifies as conscious?
Details, details!
Details Make the Difference
Paying attention to details is important even when we are not striving to define something. Often they are the key to solving a problem.
In my field of higher education, we have noticed that way too many students do not advance even to their second year of college, much less graduate in four years. That’s a loss for all of those students, but also a loss for a world that could benefit from their enhanced ability to work, serve, and solve problems.
To graduate from college, of course, students need to learn the subject matter in their classes, so we might assume the key to helping these students persist and graduate is an academic solution. In a small study I conducted several years ago, however, I noticed something interesting. Among students who reported an intention to leave college early, the vast majority did not cite academics as the reason. Instead, they reported issues related to family, work, motivation, mental and physical health, and finances. (I am by no means the only person to notice such factors.)
If we want to help these students, we can work from an incomplete and largely inaccurate (although perfectly rational) conclusion based on our limited understanding (“Hire more tutors!” “Teach study skills!”), or we can pay attention to the details and devise a solution that addresses those details. I think we can all agree on which approach is more likely to succeed.
I could cite numerous other examples of the importance of details from a variety of fields—a measurement mishap that doomed a Mars orbiter, the misplaced decimal point that cost Spain millions of dollars in submarine construction, and so on—but let me focus on just one, which illustrates the cost of missing some important details.
In a campaign known as the Great Leap Forward, China set out to reduce the population of sparrows, which were known to eat grain seeds. The thought was that reducing the number of these birds would preserve more seeds and thus lead to greater agricultural production. Alas, these sparrows also consumed locusts, which are famous for consuming crops (on biblical proportions, no less). After an ambitious campaign succeeded in driving down the number of sparrows (to local extinction in some cases), locusts were free to eat up huge portions of crops, and the Great Chinese Famine led to the starvation of millions. After nearly eliminating sparrows, China wound up importing a quarter million to solve the problem it had brought on itself because the government ignored or dismissed a key detail that scientists had recognized.
It’s easy to overlook details and rely on initial impressions or our guts, especially when we are beset with all the distractions of modern life, but then Lewis had his own pesky problems—grizzlies, mountain crossings, an 18-mile portage over prickly pear cactus, the kinds of things that come with a two-year trek over thousands of miles of wilderness. If Lewis were alive today to hear us whine about driving kids to soccer camp, he might reply, “Cry me a Missouri River.”
If Lewis could manage to focus despite everything raining (and snowing and hailing) down on him, we can, too. Paying attention pays big dividends.



Comments